30-min call with RobBook a proof-of-concept call
Job 03 · Estimating

// Mechanical contractors · Bid day

Equipment quotes, leveled against the schedule before your estimator picks one.

Bid leveling for the equipment on a commercial mechanical bid, tested as a free AI proof of concept on 20 to 30 rep quotes from bids you already priced. AI sets each chiller, air handler, rooftop unit, pump and drive quote beside the equipment schedule and the spec section, and lists every gap and exclusion for the estimator who chooses.

Book a proof-of-concept call30 minutes with Rob
Past rep quotes
20 to 30
Quotes picked by AI
None
System access
None

// The one job

Four reps quoted the rooftop units. One sheet goes into the bid.

On bid day, quotes arrive from the reps for each manufacturer the spec allows: a cover letter, a model list and a page of fine-print notes. Your estimator matches every scheduled tag to a model, checks capacity, efficiency and electrical data, notes the options, startup and warranty each quote carries, and covers what one includes and another leaves out.

In the proof of concept, AI reads the same quotes, schedules and spec sections and drafts the leveling sheet: a row per scheduled tag, a column per quote, each cell showing what the quote states and on which page, with gaps and exclusions listed under each quote. Prices stay exactly as the rep wrote them. Your estimator holds every draft against the sheet they built on bid day.

Rep quoteAs received
Tags quoted
Model
Startup
Warranty
OptionIncludedExcluded
Illustration, not a rep's quote
Lined up against
schedule and spec
Leveling sheetDraft
Schedule tag
Spec section
Quote A
Quote B
ItemMeets scheduleGap or exclusion
Illustration, not your leveling sheet

// Where it gets hard

Why two equipment quotes rarely line up row for row

Each tag points to its own spec section. Owner specs number equipment by MasterFormat: Michigan State University's standard puts indoor air handlers in 23 73 13, Modular Indoor Central-Station Air-Handling Units, the University of Maryland, Baltimore puts rooftop units in 23 74 13, and New York State's master spec splits rooftop units into 23 74 16.12 for intermediate capacity and 23 74 16.13 for large, with scroll chillers in 23 64 23. The drive may sit outside Division 23: the Michigan State standard sends variable frequency controllers to the Division 26 section on variable frequency motor controllers. So a quote with a factory-mounted drive is read against two sections, and a quote without one leaves open who furnishes it.

Ratings only compare under the same rules. New York's rooftop section calls for AHRI 210/240 ratings on units under 65,000 Btu/h and AHRI 340/360 on larger ones. Under 10 CFR 431.97, air-cooled commercial package units of 65,000 Btu/h and up built from January 1, 2023 meet a federal IEER level, and those built from January 1, 2029 meet one in IVEC, a metric that also counts economizing and ventilation energy. Specs citing ASHRAE 90.1 point to Table 6.8.1-1, Electrically Operated Unitary Air Conditioners and Condensing Units, or Table 6.8.1-3, Water-Chilling Packages, where a chiller may take Path A or, where the table gives one, Path B, but must meet both the full-load and the part-load figure of its path. Clean water pumps built since January 27, 2020 carry a DOE pump energy index, capped at 1.00 for the classes the rule lists. The draft sets each stated rating beside the scheduled one and the rule cited, and certifies nothing.

Options decide what a price covers. Specs split items between the unit maker and other trades, and quotes follow. The Maryland standard has the unit manufacturer provide the roof curb, 14 inches high, and a roofing contractor install it, on a renovation the one who maintains the existing roof's warranty. New York's large rooftop section lets the engineer take controls, dampers and damper operators from the Division 23 control sections or from the unit maker, keeps a unit-mounted disconnect only where the electrical sections don't carry one, and asks for minimum circuit ampacity and maximum overcurrent protection on the single power connection. Extra materials hide in Part 1: Michigan State asks for three sets of filters for each air handler, for construction, for acceptance and for the end of warranty, plus a set of belts for each fan.

Startup and warranty drift furthest. Most of these sections want startup by a factory-authorized service representative; chillers ask more. New York's scroll chiller section can require the manufacturer's representative on site for a set number of days to leak test, evacuate, charge, start up, calibrate controls and train staff, plus cooling-season startup and winter shutdown through the first year, a second startup when the first cooling season begins if the chiller started in winter, the first refrigerant and oil charge, and factory tests the owner may witness. Its warranty can cover the compressor, evaporator, condenser or whole assembly for five years, materials only, labor only, or both. Maryland adds at least three years on rooftop ignition modules and control boards; New York, at least five on large rooftop heat exchangers.

What your estimator will check first: tags with no matching model, capacity or electrical data that miss the schedule, ratings stated under a different metric, curbs, drives, controls and spare filters left out without a word, startup short of the spec, warranty terms below it, parts-only coverage where labor was asked for, and freight, lead time and the date each quote expires.

// What you send

What the test needs from your estimating desk

Five or six past bids
Copies only
01

Rep quotes from past bids

20 to 30 equipment quotes as the reps sent them, across five or six bids, with every revision and its email. Include a bid where a quote changed late.

02

Schedules and spec sections

The mechanical equipment schedules and the Division 23 sections for those bids, any Division 26 section that covers drives, and the addenda that changed them.

03

The sheets your estimator built

The leveling sheet behind each bid, with the adds for missing scope and the quote that went into your number. This is the answer key the drafts are scored against.

04

NDA first, look-alikes if needed

Rep quotes carry prices given to you in confidence, so the NDA is signed before any file moves. If a bid can't leave the office, we build a look-alike set with your estimator.

// Before it starts

Settled before the first quote moves

The owner names who judges the drafts and writes down what counts as a pass, before any quote is sent.

Leveling test termsOwner signs off
Reviewer
Named by the owner. Usually the estimator or chief estimator who levels equipment today.
Success criteria
In writing first, including how a missed exclusion counts
Quote choice
Your estimator's, on every package
Price
A price range for the live job, set out first
NDA
Signed before any quote, schedule or spec moves

// How it's judged

Draft sheets beside the ones your estimator used

Bid by bid
Tag by tag
Same 20 to 30 quotesYour estimator's sheetThe proof of concept
Every scheduled tag matched to a quoted modelScored on your bidsScored on your bids
Capacity, efficiency and electrical data against the scheduleScored on your bidsScored on your bids
Curbs, drives, controls and spare materials, in or outScored on your bidsScored on your bids
Startup, warranty, freight and lead time for each quoteScored on your bidsScored on your bids
Exclusions listed, including ones a quote never statesScored on your bidsScored on your bids
Questions left for your estimatorScored on your bidsScored on your bids
Still blank. No cell is filled until your own past bids have been drafted.Your estimator scores each row against the criteria agreed first.

// After a yes

About 30 days on live bids

After your estimator's yes, the job runs for about 30 days on live bids, building each sheet as the rep quotes come in.

A person reads every sheet before it feeds a number. Each gap names the quote and the page it came from, and questions for a rep are written out for your estimator to ask, never sent.

Before signing you see the live job's fixed price. Anything after it is quoted on its own, with monthly support from the day a job goes live.

// After leveling

What could come next

Ranked ideas
One job at a time
  1. 01

    Buyout tracking

    After award, each equipment order your team releases tracked against its approved submittal, release date and promised ship date.

    Next
  2. 02

    Sub quotes, leveled the same way

    Insulation, balancing and controls quotes set against the spec sections that name their scope.

    Then
  3. 03

    Closeout documents

    Startup reports and warranties for the same equipment gathered against the spec when the job turns over.

    After that

// One hard limit

It never picks a quote.

Which rep gets the order, what is added to cover a gap and the number in your bid are your estimator's calls. The proof of concept never prices a bid, orders equipment or contacts a rep, and it works only on copies: it reads each quote, sets it beside the schedule and the spec, and lists what doesn't match.

Priced per job. You get a range before the proof of concept and a fixed price before you sign.

The range comes on the call, once we know how many bids you price in a month and how many equipment packages a typical bid carries.

// Questions

Equipment leveling questions from estimators

Will it tell us which quote to use?
No. It shows where each quote meets the schedule and the spec and where it falls short, with the page each answer came from. The choice, and any add to cover a gap, stay with your estimator.
Our reps send PDFs, emails and spreadsheets. Does the format matter?
No. Send each quote the way it arrived, revisions included. The draft works from the latest version your estimator had and notes which earlier version it replaced.
Does it check whether a unit meets the energy code?
It sets each quote's stated rating beside the scheduled value and the table or federal rule the spec cites, and marks any gap. Whether a unit complies is for your engineer and estimator to settle, and the draft never says that it does.
What if a rep quotes something other than the basis of design?
The draft lays out how the quoted unit differs from the scheduled one: size, weight, electrical data, options and connections, wherever the quote states them. Whether the engineer will accept it stays an open question for your estimator.
Rob Eason

Rob Eason, founder

// Book a proof-of-concept call

Bring the quotes from a bid you priced last month.

30 minutes with Rob. Tell us your company, your role, the job you'd test and about how many bids your estimators price in a month. Keep rep quotes and specs back until the NDA is signed.

  • Co-owned a 60-employee financial services firm and sold his share to his partner.
  • Ran GOSO Technologies, a Boston solar company rated 5/5 across 24 Google reviews.
  • 5/5 across 83 reviews in HighLevel's Certified Admin Directory.
  • 4.3/5 from 6 Google reviews of Massmarket AI.
  • Every directory and Google review, critical ones included, is shown word for word at massmarket.ai/reviews.
  • Takes every proof-of-concept call himself.